Auto Insurance in Fort Myers (33907)

Florida · Below Average · 38th percentile statewide

$536/6mo
Median across 5 carriers
Cheapest: $461Spread: $426State avg: $658

Carrier Rates in 33907

6-month premiums from SERFF rate filings. Standard driver profile.

GEICOCheapest
$461/6mo
USAA
$498/6mo
Progressive
$536/6mo
Allstate
$739/6mo
State Farm
$887/6mo

How 33907 Compares

Fort Myers (33907) is below average for auto insurance in Florida, ranking in the 38th percentile.

The cheapest carrier is GEICO at $461/6mo — 48% less than the most expensive (State Farm at $887).

The median premium of $536 is 19% below the Florida statewide median of $658.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is auto insurance in Fort Myers (33907)?

The median 6-month premium in Fort Myers (33907) is $536 across 5 carriers. Premiums range from $461 to $887, based on SERFF regulatory rate filing data for a standard driver profile.

What's the cheapest auto insurance in 33907?

GEICO offers the lowest rate in 33907 at $461/6mo. That's 48% less than the most expensive option (State Farm at $887/6mo). Actual premiums vary based on your driving record, vehicle, and coverage selections.

Why is auto insurance below average in 33907?

Auto insurance rates in Fort Myers (33907) are influenced by territory rating factors including urban density, traffic patterns, claims frequency, and theft rates. Fort Myers ranks in the 38th percentile statewide, meaning it's below average compared to other Florida ZIP codes. Carriers use these geographic risk factors alongside driver-specific variables to set premiums.

Other carriers in Florida

Want full rate data for 33907?

Access ZIP-level rate data across all 5 carriers, 397 ZIP codes, multiple vehicles, and 3 coverage tiers. Updated within days of each new filing.